Second opinions, and pain that keeps coming back.
You’ve had the treatment. Maybe a few rounds of it. It helped for a while, then it came back. Or it never really went.
We do a lot of second opinions at City Physio & Pilates. Not because other people get it wrong, but because some problems need a fresh set of eyes, more time, and a team that enjoys the hard ones.
Who this is for
A second opinion could be worth it if:
- you’ve had physio, chiro, massage or other treatment and things haven’t settled
- your pain keeps coming back in the same place, or keeps moving somewhere new
- you have pain in more than one area and nobody has joined the dots
- you’ve been told you need surgery or injections and want another look first
- you’ve been told it’s “just wear and tear”, “just stress” or “just something you live with”
- you simply want someone to look at the whole picture before you decide what’s next
Bring your scans, letters and the list of everything you’ve tried. It’s all useful.
How we work
We’re a highly experienced, collaborative team, and we hold ourselves to high academic and clinical standards. We love the clinical nuance: the details that don’t quite fit, and the patterns that only show up when you look at the whole person rather than the sore bit.
Every assessment follows a structured diagnostic process. We take a detailed history, test our ideas properly, and rule things in and out before we start treating. That way, the plan is built on what’s actually going on, not on a guess.
We keep up with the latest evidence, and ongoing education, collaboration and discussion are central to how City Physio works. Tricky cases get talked through as a team, so you could get the benefit of more than one experienced head. That’s why we see so many second opinions and so much recurring pain.
We’re a physio clinic first. Not a sales funnel, and not a retail store. A lot of the industry has drifted towards packages, upsells and a wall of braces at the front desk, with more attention on the funnel than on how the patient is actually going. We’d rather spend the appointment working out what’s wrong. We won’t sell you a compression sleeve, a brace or a ten-session block unless you genuinely need it, and if you don’t, we’ll tell you.
Pain that keeps coming back
Pain that keeps returning often has a reason that hasn’t been found yet. The sore spot might be where the problem shows up, but not where it starts.
Sometimes the driver is somewhere else in the body: a stiff rib cage feeding a sore neck, a foot changing how the knee and hip load, or an old injury that changed how you move. Sometimes it’s load, sleep, stress or training patterns. Often it’s a mix.
Our job is to find what might be driving it, explain it in plain English, and give you a plan that targets the cause rather than chasing the symptom. We can’t promise it won’t come back. We can promise a proper look.
What happens at a second opinion
Book a standard appointment with any of our physios. There’s no special appointment type to find.
- Before: gather your scans, reports, letters and a rough timeline of what you’ve tried.
- On the day: a detailed history, then a thorough physical assessment. We’ll look beyond the painful area.
- Before you leave: the aim is that you leave with our honest view of what’s going on, what might be driving it, and what we’d suggest next. Sometimes that’s treatment with us. Sometimes it’s a referral, more investigation, or reassurance that you’re on the right track.
- Afterwards: with your permission, we’ll write to your GP, specialist or referring practitioner so everyone’s on the same page.
Who you might see
The whole clinical team does second opinions. Who suits you depends on what’s going on.
Nicola is an APA Titled Pain Physiotherapist and an Orofacial Myologist, with a Master of Pain Management specialising in orofacial pain. She has extensive experience in chronic pain and craniofacial pain, anything across the head, face, jaw and neck, with a particular focus on getting the diagnosis right. She keeps up with the field more than is strictly healthy: she’s a regular at ANZAOP, moderates More Than Jaw, a clinician-only forum, and joins the Harvard Interdisciplinary Pain & Headache Rounds case presentations. If your pain is long-standing, or anywhere from the neck up, she’s a good place to start.
Elizabeth is certified in the Integrated Systems Model, as taught by Diane Lee, and has an eye for pain that keeps coming back. She’s particularly good at linking pain in several areas to what might be driving it, including rib, neck and foot problems.
Matt is an APA Titled Sports and Exercise Physiotherapist, a title the Australian Physiotherapy Association gives for advanced training and experience in that field. He has extensive experience in sport, including working on TV shows like Ninja Warrior, along with rheumatology and neurological spinal presentations. He also has a special interest in multifocal pain and complex presentations. If your problem involves more than one area, or headache is part of a bigger picture, he’s a good place to start.
Ed has additional training in headache, jaw and vestibular problems, and plenty of experience with stubborn dizziness that hasn’t settled elsewhere. He looks at the link between the upper neck and the trigeminal system, the nerve network for the face and head, which can sit behind recurrent neck stiffness or workplace injuries that never fully settle. He also sees low back pain, knee injuries and painful necks, and has an eye for a complete rehab program: he aims to make yours tailored, evidence based and genuinely interesting.
Christie has over a decade of experience in high-level sport and working with elite athletes. She thinks outside the box and looks at the whole picture when managing an injury. Recurring stress fractures? Want to get back to running after having a baby but haven’t managed it yet? Play lots of sport and want someone across all of it? She’s your go-to.
Not sure who to book? Call us and we’ll suggest someone.
Common questions
Do I need to book a special second opinion appointment?
No. Book a standard appointment with any of our physios. If you're not sure who'd suit your problem, call us and we'll suggest someone.
Do I need a referral?
No. You can book directly. If a GP, specialist or another practitioner has sent you, bring their letter and we'll keep them in the loop.
What should I bring?
Any scans and reports, letters from doctors or specialists, a list of medications, and a rough timeline of what you've tried and what happened. Even "it helped for a week, then came back" is useful.
Will you tell me if I'm already on the right track?
Yes. Sometimes a second opinion is reassurance that your current plan makes sense, with a tweak or two. We'll tell you straight.
I've been told I need surgery or injections. Can you help me decide?
We can give you our view of what's going on and whether there might be other options worth trying first. The decision is yours and your doctor's, and we're happy to talk with your surgeon or GP.
Can you stop my pain coming back?
We can't promise that, and we'd be wary of anyone who does. What we can do is look for what might be driving it, explain it clearly, and give you a plan that targets the cause, which could make it less likely to keep returning.
Related services
Still sore after everything you’ve tried? It might be time for a fresh look.
Book a standard appointment with any of our physios online, or call us and we’ll help you choose.
hello@cityphysio.com.au
Shop 10, Level 6, 25 Martin Place
